Joe List reads an X-rated fan love letter, Mark Normand throws an X-rated Halloween party (a fire-juggler on a unicycle, then the cops), and a stuffed chicken turns up on Mark’s stoop. Plus the Undertaker’s tickets, deadnaming and the Expos.
Chapters
- 0:00 Election week and the podcast awards.
- 2:37 The blindfold match and the Undertaker’s tickets.
- 6:45 The fan love letter.
- 12:28 Mark’s Halloween party.
- 22:54 Joe vs. the models.
- 25:05 Ads: Quince and Raycon.
- 28:17 Back at the party: the cops, the outfits, the juggler.
- 40:18 Halloween in New York and the marathon.
- 45:56 The porch-gift mystery.
- 1:01:15 Millennials vs. Gen X; deadnaming questions.
- 1:06:58 UMass, the Expos and team renames.
- 1:08:47 Skankfest roast and tour plugs.
Show more
Want this section to go deeper? Share this page with the creators and have them sign up so we can get permission to dig deeper into this episode.
Key topics
- 6:45 7:57 11:03 The fan love letter — Joe reads an explicit fan letter aloud — and later learns it ended up on Reddit.
- 3:29 53:59 The Undertaker’s tickets — Booked for the pod, promised six tickets at the Garden, then bailed — and Chuck missed out.
- 12:31 15:08 17:19 Mark’s sex-club Halloween party — A KitKatClub-style theme, a juggler on a unicycle, and the cops at the door over noise.
- 22:54 Joe vs. the models — Small talk with the party’s models: “every cliché is true.”
- 45:56 46:42 The porch-gift mystery — A stuffed chicken, then a jug of water, on Mark’s stoop. The culprit turns out to be someone he knows.
- 1:03:35 1:06:17 1:08:12 Deadnaming and team names — From Caitlyn Jenner and Elliot Page to the Expos and UMass’s vacated Final Four.
- 1:01:15 1:02:04 Millennials vs. Gen X — Where the hosts land — Xennials?
Show more
Want this section to go deeper? Share this page with the creators and have them sign up so we can get permission to dig deeper into this episode.
People
On this episode
Mark Normand
The Comedian List · marknormandcomedy.com · Tour dates
Co-host. Throws a Halloween party with a sex-club theme (a fire-juggler on a unicycle, then the cops), solves the mystery of a stuffed chicken and a water jug on his stoop, and plugs his 2027 theater tour and movie. 0:00 12:03 15:12
Joe List
The Comedian List · comedianjoelist.com · Tour dates
Co-host. Reads an explicit fan love letter (which then turned up on Reddit), recalls the Martel–Roberts blindfold match, makes small talk with models at Mark’s party, and plugs his tour and a horror film he’s raising money for. 0:00 6:19 19:51
Chuck
The show’s producer — “Discount Chuck.” Missed out on the wrestling tickets, doubles down on his Boston-bombing theory, and plugs his podcast Funbearable and a show he’s making with the Impractical Jokers crew. 3:58 4:55 7:13
People mentioned
Amy Poehler
“Amy Poehler just wins best podcast” — the hosts on the new podcast award. 1:11
Marc Maron
Named among the podcasters who were up for the award. 1:24
Adam Carolla
Same list — “a little bit of an underdog.” 1:24
Joe Rogan
The Comedian List · The Celeb List · Best Movies & TV Shows · Wikipedia
The biggest podcast wasn’t in the running: he said he didn’t submit and didn’t want to pay the fee. 1:30 18:42 41:04
Louis C.K.
Won a Grammy, and once floated submitting Joe’s film Fourth of July to the Oscars; Joe notes Louis paid for the whole movie. 1:41
Nick DiPaolo
The Oscars joke: “Nick DiPaolo is gonna win best supporting actor?” 1:50
Rick Martel
One half of the WrestleMania VII blindfold match. 2:28
Jake “The Snake” Roberts
The other half — Joe’s childhood blindfold-match memory. 2:28
The Undertaker
Mark Calaway. Was booked for the podcast and promised six tickets to the wrestling show at the Garden, then bailed — and a friend of the show used the seats. 3:29 53:59
Kieran Culkin
Sitting near the show’s friend at the Garden — “an Oscar winner.” 4:25 5:31
Madonna
Also in the Garden seats, per the friend’s report. 4:25
Matthew Rhys
“The main actor from Widow’s Bay” — another of the Garden neighbors. “That guy’s a beast.” 5:25
Jerry Seinfeld
“What are you, Seinfeld?” — when it turns out a host has a garage full of old studio stuff. 6:22
Eminem
A joke during the love-letter reading. 9:07
Dr. Seuss
A rhyme joke, and later a Halloween-costume riff. 9:52 1:01:07
Busta Rhymes
A party-guest joke — “Buster of Rhymes.” 12:18
Shane Gillis
The Celeb List · The Comedian List · Best Movies & TV Shows · Wikipedia
Mark mentions Shane while setting up the party’s dress-up theme. 15:31
Jake Velasquez
Comic invited to the party; brought his girlfriend’s friends. 15:41 20:15
Jordan Jensen
The Comedian List · Best Movies & TV Shows
Name-checked in the party guest talk. 16:25
Bill Cosby
“Two things can be true” — the funny-vs.-person debate. 20:31 1:07:40
Dane Cook
The Comedian List · Best Movies & TV Shows · Wikipedia
A party guest’s Dane Cook shirt. 20:44
Tom Dustin
Subject of Joe’s documentary, Tom Dustin: Portrait of a Comedian. 22:54
Matt Ruby
Comic at the party; helped get Marcus Monroe up on the unicycle. 24:24
Zach Zimmerman
Comic at the party. 33:59
Katie Hannigan
Comic at the party. 34:02
Marcus Monroe
Juggler-comic who rode a unicycle and juggled fire at Mark’s party, doing impressions as he went. 34:32
Mark Zuckerberg
One of Marcus’s impressions. 34:57
Jeffrey Epstein
Another of the party impressions. 35:00
Donald Trump
Another impression. 35:00
Joe Biden
And another. 35:05
Jay Leno
How the devil-costumed juggler looked: “like Jay Leno with a red face and horns.” 36:16 56:21
Bill Murray
Name-checked in the Ghostbusters talk. 40:42
Whitney Houston
A dark bathtub joke. 41:41
Colonel Sanders
Who left the stuffed chicken? “Is it Colonel Sanders?” 46:29
Adam Ray
His kid is due around the same time; the hosts riff on Ray’s Dr. Phil. 1:00:45
Phil McGraw
“Imagine that’s your dad” — Adam Ray’s best-known impression. 1:01:04
Jack Kevorkian
The end of the “Dr.” costume list. 1:01:07
Caitlyn Jenner
Bruce Jenner’s Olympic decathlon comes up in the deadnaming talk; a rumor that she’s “transitioning back” gets called a myth on air. 1:03:02
Laura Jane Grace
Singer of Against Me!, raised in the deadnaming talk. 1:05:33
Elliot Page
Juno star, in the same conversation. 1:05:57
Lou Roe
UMass player from the 1990s teams. 1:07:22
Dan Soder
Named for the Skankfest roast of Joe. 1:08:59
Mike Lawrence
Also on the roast. 1:08:59
Luis J. Gomez
Skankfest’s founder; the hosts quote last year’s roast joke about him. 1:09:06
Show more
Want this section to go deeper? Share this page with the creators and have them sign up so we can get permission to dig deeper into this episode.
Watch & read
The Polar Express (2004) — The title pun — the “Poller Express” is election week. Amazon 1:11
Fourth of July (2022) — Joe’s film with Louis C.K. Louis once floated an Oscars submission; “Fourth of July 2” comes up later as a joke. JustWatch 2:00 1:10:27
Widow’s Bay — The Matthew Rhys series the hosts are into. JustWatch 5:25
Jurassic Park (1993) — A T-Rex line during the love letter. Amazon 8:32
Tom Dustin: Portrait of a Comedian — Joe’s film about the comic Tom Dustin — his opener with the models at the party. Find it: YouTube 22:54
Ghostbusters (1984) — Halloween stop at the movie’s firehouse. Amazon 40:18
One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest — Mark reaches for it before landing on Mockingbird. Where to read: Amazon 47:52
To Kill a Mockingbird — Mark compares his porch gifts to Boo Radley’s knothole trinkets. Where to read: Amazon 47:57
Impractical Jokers — Chuck is making a show with the Impractical Jokers crew. JustWatch 51:42 1:13:24
Juno (2007) — Elliot Page’s film, in the deadnaming talk. Amazon 1:05:47
Sleepless in Seattle (1993) — Near Joe’s Baltimore club: “the Sleepless in Seattle house is right there.” Amazon 1:09:44
Funbearable — Chuck’s podcast. Find it: YouTube 1:12:29
Show more
Want this section to go deeper? Share this page with the creators and have them sign up so we can get permission to dig deeper into this episode.
Products
Reddit — Where the love letter later turned up. · reddit.com 6:46 7:32 20:35
Equinox — A line from the love letter. · equinox.com 9:48
GoPro — Mark’s plan for catching whoever left the porch gifts. · gopro.com 18:21
Pixy Stix — Trying to name the candy “full of sugar” in a skinny tube. Amazon 42:33
Jolly Rancher — Same candy guessing game. · hersheyland.com 42:46
Cadbury — The Easter bunny aside. · cadbury.co.uk 44:25
Twizzlers — A candy run idea. · twizzlers.com 53:14
Ritz Crackers — Crackers in the studio — “putting on the Ritz.” Amazon 1:11:56
Show more
Want this section to go deeper? Share this page with the creators and have them sign up so we can get permission to dig deeper into this episode.
Places & tour dates
Madison Square Garden — The wrestling show the Undertaker offered tickets to. (Official site) 3:58
KitKatClub, Berlin — Inspiration for the party theme. Wikipedia 15:12
Pete’s Tavern — Old New York bar, in the party story. (Official site) 31:48
Ghostbusters firehouse (Hook & Ladder 8) — The Halloween stop in Manhattan. Wikipedia 40:18
New York City Marathon — Watched from the course. (Official site) 44:46
BAM (Brooklyn Academy of Music) — Landmark on the marathon route. (Official site) 45:03
Comedy Cellar — The neighbors’ double-date idea. (Official site) 52:23 53:45
Port Comedy Club, Baltimore (Joe) — Joe List, Nov 19–21, 2026. (Official site) 1:09:31
The Vic Theatre, Chicago (Joe) — Joe List, Mar 6, 2027. (Official site) 1:09:50
The Wilbur, Boston (Joe) — Joe List, Apr 17, 2027. (Official site) 1:09:50
Comedy Zone, Charlotte (Mark) — Mark Normand, Dec 10–12, 2026. (Official site) 1:12:01
Turning Stone, Verona NY (Mark) — Mark Normand, Dec 18, 2026. (Official site) 1:12:05
Foxwoods, Mashantucket CT (Mark) — Mark Normand, Dec 19, 2026. (Official site) 1:12:05
Show more
Want this section to go deeper? Share this page with the creators and have them sign up so we can get permission to dig deeper into this episode.
Ads
- Quince (25:15) — Select “Tuesdays with Stories” when asked where you heard about Quince. quince.com
- Raycon (27:00) — buyraycon.com/tuesdaysOPEN
Show more
Want this section to go deeper? Share this page with the creators and have them sign up so we can get permission to dig deeper into this episode.
Go Deeper: rabbit holes
Rabbit holes from this episode — topics, places, and works actually discussed, with a place to start reading.
- 1:11 Golden Globes’ first podcast award — The category Amy Poehler’s podcast won. Wikipedia
- 1:44 Grammy for Best Comedy Album — Joe’s point about who submits. Wikipedia
- 2:00 Fourth of July (2022) — Joe’s film with Louis C.K. Wikipedia
- 2:37 WrestleMania VII — The 1991 card with the Martel–Roberts blindfold match. Wikipedia
- 3:29 53:59 The Undertaker — Mark Calaway’s career and The Streak. Wikipedia
- 12:50 23:18 24:08 Ketamine — It came up in the party story; here’s the background. Wikipedia
- 15:12 KitKatClub — The Berlin club behind Mark’s party theme. Wikipedia
- 34:54 Marcus Monroe — The juggler-comic known for costumed subway sets. Official site
- 40:18 The Ghostbusters firehouse — Hook & Ladder 8, the real firehouse from the film. Wikipedia
- 44:46 NYC Marathon — The race the hosts watched. Wikipedia
- 47:52 Boo Radley’s knothole gifts — The Mockingbird parallel to Mark’s porch gifts. Wikipedia
- 50:03 Acid flashbacks (HPPD) — “There’s a word for it” — what the term means. Wikipedia
- 52:23 53:45 Comedy Cellar — The club in the double-date story. Official site
- 1:01:15 1:02:04 Xennials — The micro-generation between Gen X and Millennials. Wikipedia
- 1:03:35 1:06:17 1:08:12 Deadnaming — The term the caller asked about. Wikipedia
- 1:04:37 Sex-selective abortion — The hosts’ tangent on parents choosing a baby’s sex; background reading. Wikipedia
- 1:06:58 1:12:44 UMass’s vacated 1996 Final Four — Why the run came off the books. Wikipedia
- 1:07:51 Montreal Expos to Washington Nationals — The 2005 move. Wikipedia
- 1:08:06 Washington Bullets to Wizards — The 1997 rename. Wikipedia
- 1:08:22 Sudan — The aside that “nobody cares” about it. Wikipedia
- 1:08:47 Skankfest — The festival behind the roast of Joe. Official site
- 1:09:44 Sleepless in Seattle in Baltimore — The film’s Fells Point scenes. Wikipedia
- 1:12:44 Boston Marathon bombing — Chuck says there were co-conspirators; the official record names two brothers. Wikipedia
Show more
Want this section to go deeper? Share this page with the creators and have them sign up so we can get permission to dig deeper into this episode.
Show plugs
- 1:10:12 Joe List — tour and a horror film — Tour dates, and a horror film with a big actor attached that he’s raising money for (not his script). punchup.live/joelist
- 1:11:39 1:13:44 Tuesdays with Stories Patreon — Extra episodes. patreon.com/tuesdays · tuesdayspod.com
- 1:12:14 Mark Normand — 2027 theater tour — Announcing soon; “wheels are in motion” on his movie. punchup.live/marknormand
- 1:12:29 Chuck — Funbearable — Chuck’s podcast. He’s @DiscountChuck on Instagram and X.
Show more
Want this section to go deeper? Share this page with the creators and have them sign up so we can get permission to dig deeper into this episode.
More from this show — All Tuesdays with Stories notes · Brain Queef | Tuesdays with Stories #681
Show notes are a summary, not a full transcript. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page may be affiliate links through Amazon and other partner programs we participate in now or in the future. If you buy through those links, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.